Latest in five-year-long legal battle behind Birmingham’s ‘The Square’ development sees court reject £21m fortification damages application
The long-running legal battle over Birmingham’s landmark development The Square has reached another significant milestone, after the High Court rejected the defendants’ application seeking a fortification payment of £21m.
In a bid to seek security for potential damages caused by injunctions imposed by the court, property developer Samuel Ginda and his companies – 2020 Living Limited, Taylor Grange 2 Limited and TGDM One Limited – approached the courts requesting the claimant – Leicester-based investor Sanman Property Management Ltd – pay £21m into court in anticipation of a potential damages claim for a number of losses incurred by the defendants said to total £33m as a condition for various injunctions continuing. However, the application was dismissed in full for lack of evidential basis despite the court applying a lower threshold test, which only required the defendants to establish a ‘serious issue to be tried’ test for its alleged losses.
James Woolstenhulme, dispute resolution partner at Shakespeare Martineau, who is leading the claim on behalf of Sanman, said: “A point of contention was not just significant gaps and inconsistencies in evidence presented by the defendants, but also what threshold an applicant must meet when seeking fortification: whether the traditional ‘good arguable case’ test applied, or the ‘serious issue to be tried’ test adopted in Dos Santos v Unitel SA in respect of freezing injunctions.
“The judgment provides important clarification, with the court applying Dos Santos because the fortification threshold is tethered to that governing the underlying freezing injunction. However, the judge made clear that the application would have failed even on the lower test advocated by the defendants.” The ongoing dispute stemming from an ‘unlawful conspiracy’ to exclude Sanman from profits tied to the proposed 220-room hotel and current 30-storey residential tower in the city’s Broad Street has reached its fifth year of litigation.
Earlier this year, Ginda successfully appealed the court’s original decision to strike out his evidence, with a retrial due in March 2027. Alongside the original claim, Ginda is also being accused of contempt of proceedings, which, if found guilty of contempt of court, could see the Birmingham developer serve jail time. Sanman Property Management Ltd brought the claim against the defendants after providing the developer with a loan to secure an option to acquire the development land in Broad Street. In return, it was agreed Sanman would receive interest and a split of the profits.
However, the court heard that a sequence of transactions later occurred, without Sanman’s knowledge or involvement, that took the land purchased with Sanman’s assistance out of 2020 Living’s ownership and thus excluded Sanman from the profit generated. Sanman issued a claim for the loan value (which was repaid in 2021 following an initial judgment), interest and anticipated profits. Litigators at law firm Shakespeare Martineau, who act on behalf of Sanman, revealed the companies benefiting from the transactions for the development land were in fact owned by the same director (and beneficial owner) as 2020 Living, Mr Samuel Ginda.
Timeline
· September 2024 – Shakespeare Martineau quickly applies for court order on behalf of Sanman for a declaration that the defendants’ evidence be struck out and debarred after multiple deadlines and extensions were missed. Ginda et al make cross application for relief from sanction, which is dismissed. Sanman’s application was successful on both strike out and debarral while the defendants’ was dismissed.
· October 2024 – Trial on liability takes place where Sanman proved its case on the documentation and evidence and was awarded judgment in its favour. At the same trial, Sanman’s co-claimant Midland Premier Properties Limited – also represented by Shakespeare Martineau – obtained a judgment of £560m against the first defendant, property developer Rakesh Doal, on a separate claim.
· January 2025 – Second application by the defendants for relief from sanction, which was dismissed at a hearing in March 2025 and Sanman were awarded their costs, with an interim payment on account of costs and damages of £1.7m payable by the defendants was ordered by the court.
· June 2025 – High Court rejected a third application by the defendants to challenge or vary the sanction.
· January 2026 – The defendant successfully appealed the original court decision to have their claim struck out.
· November 2026 – High Court rejected the defendant’s application for £21m in fortification.
· A retrial including the Ginda et al.’s defence to be heard in March 202
Alex Ryan, partner at Shakespeare Martineau who also works on the matter, said: “It’s highly unusual for a claim to have so many freezing orders and for the legal battle to go on for so long.
“It’s a hotly contested piece of litigation, with a number of satellite allegations and push back from an aggressive defence. It’s testament to the nerve of our client and the desire for justice.” Working alongside James and Alex were Natalie Thorpe (legal director), Nicola Lediard (legal director) and Jamilah Campbell (solicitor). Hill Dickinson solicitors act on behalf of the defendants.